10400 Cemetery Road
Otisville, MI 48463
Single Family Residence · MLS # 20261087905 · Listing courtesy of Red Fox Realty LLC
About this home
Escape the hustle and bustle of everyday life and come home to serenity, tranquility and peace. Whether you're watching the sunset over the water or watching the sunrise through the trees, you won't want to leave home. This 6 acre property is located on Picnic Lake, a small serene fishing lake, and has its own dock for fishing or just relaxing. The two bedrooms are a good size and very comfortable. Living room has beautiful hardwood floors and a wood burning stove. The bathroom was remodeled in 2025, adding a large new shower. The kitchen cabinets were painted a beautiful shade of green and all new appliances were also added in 2025. Hardwood floors inside add beauty and warmth. Outside you will find a rock firepit that is perfect for those cool evenings. The woods offer wildlife galore and you will feel nothing but calm and stress free as soon as you walk the property. Views of the lake can be seen from the home and a short walk across the street has you right there at the water. Seller is leaving the 14' rowboat at the end of the dock so all you need to bring is your fishing gear and you are all set!
Interior
Systems and utilities
Exterior and lot
Taxes, HOA and more
Schools
How it compares in Otisville
Over the last 90 days, 14 homes sold in Otisville for a median of $169,000, about $167 per square foot, and the typical one went under contract in 10 days. This home is listed at $283,900, or $273 per square foot, 63% above the city median, and has been on the market 1 day. Size, condition, updates and the exact street all move the number, so treat this as context. See recent Otisville sales or ask us for the comparable sales on this one.
Property taxes for a new owner
The current owner pays about $2,673 a year. A buyer who lives here would pay about $1,618 to $4,030 a year once the taxable value resets after the sale, at the 2025 homestead rate of 28.11 mills for Forest Twp and Lakeville schools, plus the 1% administration fee. Michigan resets a home's taxable value the year after it sells, so the seller's bill isn't a good number to budget with. See the math.
Monthly payment estimate
Estimate only, 30 year fixed, includes taxes at a new owner's rate when listed. Ask us for a lender quote.
Location
Similar homes in Otisville
IDX information provided courtesy of Realcomp II Ltd. via The MJA Company at National Realty Centers, © 2026 Realcomp II Ltd. Shareholders. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The accuracy of all information, regardless of source, is not guaranteed or warranted. All information should be independently verified. Data updated Nov 14, 2026, 7:39 PM.