Should I sell my house before buying another one?
Michael Allen, Associate Broker
Updated
Short answer
For most people, selling first is the safer move because you know exactly what you have to spend and you can't get stuck with two mortgages. The tradeoff is you might need a short term place to land. If you have the equity or cash to buy first, that's easier on your life but riskier on your wallet. A lot of our clients split the difference by selling with a short stay after closing so they can move once.
This is the chicken and egg question of real estate. I talk through it with almost every move up seller, and there's no single right answer. It comes down to your money, your nerves, and how much you hate moving twice.
Option 1: Sell first
Why it's good: You know your exact budget, your offer on the next house is stronger because it isn't contingent on selling, and you'll never carry two mortgages.
The catch: You need somewhere to go if you haven't found the next place. That could mean a short term rental, staying with relatives, or storage.
The Michigan trick that helps: Ask for occupancy after closing. It's common here for a seller to stay a few days to a few weeks after closing, with the terms written into the purchase agreement (usually a daily rate and an escrow holdback that's returned when you move out on time). It gives you a cushion to close on your next home and move once.
Option 2: Buy first
Why it's good: One move, no rush, and you can prep and sell your current home empty, which usually shows better.
The catch: You need to qualify for the new mortgage while still paying the old one, or have a way to cover the down payment before your sale closes. Common ways people do it:
- A home equity line of credit on your current home, opened before you list.
- A bridge loan, which some lenders offer for exactly this situation.
- Cash savings or other assets.
Talk to a lender before you go this route. The numbers have to work if your house takes longer to sell than you hoped.
Option 3: Make your offer contingent on selling
You can write an offer that depends on your home selling. It works, but sellers usually see it as weaker, especially on homes with multiple offers. It works best when your home is already under contract or the home you want has been sitting for a while.
Option 4: Close both on the same day
Very doable with good coordination. You close on your sale in the morning and your purchase in the afternoon, and the proceeds fund the next down payment. It needs everyone's timelines to line up, so build in a little flexibility, like that occupancy period above.
The money on a typical move up
Here's the math most people are really asking about. Say your current home is worth $320,000 and you owe $180,000. Selling costs in Michigan run about 6% to 10% of the price once commission, the 0.86% transfer tax, title and prorations are counted (the full breakdown is here), so call it $25,000. That leaves about $115,000 in your pocket at closing.
Put $100,000 of that down on a $450,000 home and you're borrowing $350,000 with 22% down, so no mortgage insurance, and you still have a cushion for closing costs and the first surprise. Sell first and that's exactly how it goes. Buy first and you need to come up with the $100,000 before your sale closes, which is where the HELOC or bridge loan comes in, and you'd be paying interest on it for however long the two closings overlap.
That's why I push most people toward selling first, or toward the same day close below. The equity is real either way. The question is only whether you borrow against it for a while.
A timeline that usually works
- Week 1. Get a real number on your current home and a pre-approval on the next one so you know both ends of the budget.
- Weeks 2 to 3. Prep and list your home. Start touring, but don't write offers yet.
- Weeks 3 to 4. Homes here go under contract in about a week or two when priced right. Once yours is under contract and past inspection, write your offer on the next place with a 30 to 45 day close.
- Weeks 7 to 9. Close your sale, then your purchase, same day or a few days apart with a short occupancy agreement bridging the gap.
Two months, one move. It doesn't always land this neatly, but it does more often than people expect, and the pieces that make it work are all written into standard Michigan paperwork.
What I'd tell you, depending on your situation
- Tight on cash, comfortable staying with family for a few weeks: sell first, no question.
- Strong income, plenty of savings, hate moving twice: buy first is fine. Get the HELOC in place before you list, not after.
- Found the one and it has other offers: a sale contingency will probably lose. Either buy first with a bridge, or let it go. There will be another one.
- Buying in a slower price range than you're selling in: sell first, then take your time. You'll have leverage as a buyer with nothing to sell.
Questions I'd ask yourself
- How much equity do I have? (Our instant home value gives you a quick read.)
- Could I afford both payments for two or three months if I had to?
- How hard would a short term move be for my household, pets included?
- How competitive is the price range I'm buying in?
Homes in our area are going under contract fast right now (here's the data), which makes selling first less scary than it used to be. If you want to talk through your specific situation, give me a call. That's what I'm here for.
Quick questions
Can I stay in my house after closing in Michigan?
Yes, if the buyer agrees. Seller occupancy after closing is common in Michigan and is written into the purchase agreement, usually with a daily rate and an escrow holdback.
What is a bridge loan?
A short term loan that uses the equity in your current home to help you buy the next one before your sale closes. Not every lender offers them, so ask early.
Is a home sale contingency a bad idea?
Not always, but sellers often see it as a weaker offer. It works best when your home is already under contract or the home you want isn't getting much competition.
Can I buy a house before selling mine?
Yes, if you qualify for the new mortgage while still carrying the old one, or can cover the down payment with a HELOC, a bridge loan or savings. Line up the financing before you list, not after.
How do people sell and buy at the same time?
Most list first, go under contract, then write their offer on the next home with a 30 to 45 day close and a short occupancy agreement after their sale closes. That turns it into one move, usually within about two months.
Do I have to sell my house before buying another one?
No. It's the safer order for your money, but buying first is common when you have the income and equity to carry both for a while.
Equal Housing Opportunity. We follow the Fair Housing Act and treat every client the same.